DPFrank
 Best of Breed Posts:353
 | | 05/28/2008 3:49 PM |
| I recently did a DNA test on my mix, Piper. This was a blood test, not the new swab tests you are now seeing all over. I can't compare, I never did the swab test, but may to compare the results. According to this test done by the company" WISDOM PANEL", my dog Piper, shows a significant amount of german shepherd, distant traces of german short hair pointer and mini schnauzer, and faint signals of other breeds not strong enough to identify. The words I used above are from the report. If you check out Piper on my profile, you can only notice GSD which is what the report says as well. Interesting, I only did it for the heck of it, it cost me $160.00 beans. Below is their web site. By the way, my vet took the blood and sent it to the lab. http://www.whatsmydog.com/ Frank | | | |
|
Dobeluvr
 Champion Posts:104
 | | 05/31/2008 1:46 PM |
| | This is the second place this DNA testing has shown up on this site. IF I had an extra $160 to spend, I would be more likely to donate to a rescue group (for me it would be the Doberman rescue group, DVDPA, where I got Tyler from), or humane society than do a test on Tess, my mixed breed whom I adopted from the local humane society 8 yrs. ago. I know she's got Dobe in her which is what attracted me to her in the first place and whatever else just doesn't matter to me. Is this just a new curiosity thing to get us to spend money on? | | | |
|
Newfs
 Best in Show Posts:2542
 | | 05/31/2008 1:59 PM |
| Posted By Dobeluvr on 05/31/2008 1:46 PM
This is the second place this DNA testing has shown up on this site. Is this just a new curiosity thing to get us to spend money on? Only if you want to spend the money on the test..... I can see how some people are super curious about the breeds that created their dog..... I don't have a mixed breed dog, but I probably would get the test done, only because I am one of those kinds of people that "just need to know"! | | | |
|
DPFrank
 Best of Breed Posts:353
 | | 05/31/2008 5:05 PM |
| I donate time and money to shelters as well as the aspca all year long. | | | |
|
Mals
 Champion Posts:26
 | | 05/31/2008 7:30 PM |
| Interesting. I'm skeptical though. My immediate reaction is that I'm with Dobeluvr. How come they say that it cannot be used on pure bred dogs in their FAQ? Isn't that part of the question you're asking? What mixes are my dog and one answer might possibly it's a purebred that doesn't look it? How would they distinguish working dogs like a Husky? Dogs that were bred for their ability to perform? I'm not a geneticist so I can't tell if this company is legit or not. I looked at their publications and it's all newspaper and TV show reports. They don't list any scientific publications supporting them. I'll try to dig around a little more. Let us know if you find out any more information on the science behind this. If the evidence is from peer reviewed science publications, not if it's just someone vet off the street saying that it works. If it's true and valid, I'm interested in expanding my knowledge. I personally wouldn't do this because I really don't care what my dogs are I'm wondering if this is something like the Full Body CT scan fad a few years back. Scan of your entire body and make sure you don't have any diseases. Lot's of people made big bucks off of that while it lasted. It had no scientific evidence that it did any good and probably made things worse. The medical specialty groups turned against the people doing it. Now this is in my field so I know something about this. | | | |
|
DPFrank
 Best of Breed Posts:353
 | | 05/31/2008 7:49 PM |
| I'll dig more as well, This test could keep the thieves in check that sell over priced "designer" breeds. Frank | | | |
|
allie1964
 Best of Breed Posts:389
 | | 05/31/2008 8:04 PM |
| I would much rather spend my money on this then a WIG for my dog. That is unbelieveable. Anyways, I suppose it would be nice to know if a mixed breed has any genetic predisposition that some purebreds have. Also my black dog (shelter dog as all mine are/were) looks like a purebred Flatcoat retriever ~~ I'm sure he's not but it would be kinda nice to know if he has any in him. But like Frank I wouldn't love him any less no matter what. Haven't you ever bought anything you didnt need but you just wanted it? And no I'm not having the test done because my funds wont stretch that far but I also donate time, $$$ towels dishes etc. to shelters and animal organizations. | | | |
|
DPFrank
 Best of Breed Posts:353
 | | 05/31/2008 9:24 PM |
| | Not sure why people need to wear their badge of honor on their sleeve. I elected to do the test, big deal. one thing i never did in my life was look in other peoples pockets! | | | |
|
allie1964
 Best of Breed Posts:389
 | | 05/31/2008 9:52 PM |
| I'm not sure either Frank~ | | | |
|
Newfs
 Best in Show Posts:2542
 | | 06/01/2008 7:21 AM |
| Posted By Mals on 05/31/2008 7:30 PM Interesting. I'm skeptical though. How come they say that it cannot be used on pure bred dogs in their FAQ? Well then for me it *would* be a waste of $160.00 then. The sire & dam 's DNA of both my dogs are on file with the AKC. I personally witnessed both my dogs dangling off their momma for milk for weeks on end. The litter that my dogs was created from was also registered with the AKC....... so why on earth would I want to check to see if my Newfs are really purebreds.... I suppose if someone bought a purebred pup from a Pet Store, BYB or over the Internet, there is a really high risk that the pup may not be a purebred.... | | | |
|
Mals
 Champion Posts:26
 | | 06/02/2008 7:47 PM |
| Posted By Newfs on 06/01/2008 7:21 AM I suppose if someone bought a purebred pup from a Pet Store, BYB or over the Internet, there is a really high risk that the pup may not be a purebred.... If someone buys from a pet store, backyard breeder, etc, they have not done their homework and they are at high risk for all manner of problems; mental, physical, medical, etc etc. They are supporting a horrible practice and ending up with a non purebred is the least of their potential problems. | | | |
|